Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake

In this post we will be chasing this Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake.

FINALSwirled-Cookie-Butter-Cheesecake

I used to be afraid of cheesecake, do you believe that? Some of you know my life long fear of mayonnaise, whenever I spot  it on a table or a gathering I begin to look around suspiciously.    Is it going to be in a meal that someone serves? What am I going to do? I can’t eat it.     I begin to fear for all food served at restaurants too.  Once as a kid I ordered a grilled cheese and they put mayo on the bread.  I was outraged.  Thankfully I looked before eating it, if not I probably have fainted right there at my local mall diner.    Who makes grilled cheese with mayo by the way?  It just shouldn’t be allowed, ever.   And fast food restaurants, don’t even get me started.  My poor parents would order me a burger and we’d have to inspect it in the car before leaving. If they put mayo on it after our request not to, then my mother or father or me would march back into that burger joint and get that burger remade.  What happened if we didn’t check the burger in the car so we didn’t spot the mayo until we got home? Well I wouldn’t eat dinner.  Mayo was not getting close to me.

How does this relate to cheesecake?  In my mind anything white and creamy must have tasted like mayonnaise.    Ricotta cheese, cream cheese, sour cream, cottage cheese and many more tubs of whiteness scared me, and many still do.  I’ve come around to ricotta completely.  Sour cream?  Only if I have to and it’s well hidden.  Cottage cheese? Nope. Cream cheese…. Once I met Matthew he told me about great cheesecake was.  I was obviously very cautious of this for my mayo fear.  Finally he made me realize it’s nothing like mayo and had me take the smallest bite possible from a slice of cheesecake he was eating.  The things you do for love! Did I like what I tasted? You bet I did! I nearly finished that piece of pie.  So now I’ve grown up to eating cream cheese in cheesecake and mashed potatoes.  Will I eat cream cheese on a bagel though? Absolutely not, that’s pushing it.

Do you know about Cookie Butter, aka one of the greatest things ever invented, aka omg good get it away from me before I eat anymore, aka omg get it away from me before I eat anymore – no wait a minute, please bring it back to me?  Cookie Butter can be bought at Trader Joe’s and it basically tastes like you are eating a Gingerbread Cookie house.  Trader Joe’s suggest that you put Cookie Butter on pancakes and snacks, but whatever, I will continue to eat it with a spoon like it was meant to be eaten.  Unfortunately though after many spoonfuls worth a few days ago I realized that one 1 serving is 1 tablespoon. WHAT?   How guilty did I feel? Very.  How many more spoonfuls did I eat to get me out of this guilty depression? Many.

I don’t do drugs but I would compare Cookie Butter to a very strong drug.  Once you have it, you will always crave it.  You will change your schedule around to be near Trader Joe’s when at all possible. You will tell yourself you are only buying 1 jar then as soon as you see it will you buy multiples to have as many hits as you crave.    I am not saying I want you to become addicted to Cookie Butter because it will lead you down a long and delicious road full of your childrens missed plays and wondering if people know you are secretly hiding a Cookie Butter addiction or not.   At the same time I really want you to try Cookie Butter if you can.  I think everyone should taste this goodness once in their life because it really is magical.     I suggest buying a jar, eating 1 spoonful and then throwing it away immediately.    And then because I know this will happen, you will be scraping around your trash can at 3AM to find the rest of the jar – but I am not condoning that, it’s just what’s going to happen.   Actually I think it’s almost impossible to only eat 1 serving at a time, I’m serious.  Try it, you will fail.  I am sorry for not being more positive, but Cookie Butter… it just takes over your life.

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake_4

So one night recently I decided to eat Cookie Butter a different way then with a spoon.   Enter this Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake into my life.  This Cheesecake rules for many reasons:
It’s really really delicious.
This is meant to be a quick recipe.  I am even using a pre-made crust. Feel free to make a homemade one if you have the extra minutes.
This recipe only uses 1 8oz package of Cream Cheese. So many recipes call for 3+ packages of cream cheese, not this one.
Cookie Butter is mixed inside the cheesecake then drizzled on top.  That gives the Cheesecake a delicious cookie taste.
Repeating it’s really really delicious.

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake_1

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake_2

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake_3

I hope you give this Cookie Butter flavored Cheesecake a taste! You’ll just love it.

Swirled Cookie Butter Cheesecake
Print
Ingredients
  1. 1 9 inch graham cracker crust
  2. 8 oz package of cream cheese
  3. 1/2 cup sugar
  4. 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  5. 1 teaspoon vanilla
  6. pinch of salt
  7. 2 eggs
  8. 6 tablespoons cookie butter
Instructions
  1. Preheat your oven to 325.
  2. Beat cream cheese and sugar together until fluffy.
  3. Add lemon juice, vanilla, salt, eggs and 4 tablespoons of cookie butter. Continue beating until all combined.
  4. Pour into graham cracker crust.
  5. Bake for 30-35 minutes until set.
  6. Put remaining 2 tablespoons of cookie butter in microwave for 10 seconds until slightly melted. Drizzle over cheesecake.
  7. Chill in refrigerator. Leave cake chill for at least 1 hour before serving.
Notes
  1. If you cannot get Cookie Butter, try peanut butter instead.
Brooklyn Farm Girl http://brooklynfarmgirl.com/

60 Comments

Leave a comment
  • I’m not much of a cheesecake fan and I think you’ve converted me – and there’s not even chocolate in this! It does look amazing. And so funny about the mayo – I can totally relate. I hated it as a kid – the smell! I would make sure the sandwich guy knew I wanted nothing but the meat and bread on sandwich, particularly not mayo, and I avoided burgers. I couldn’t stand when my sister would slatter her sandwiches with the stuff. I still don’t like it much now on its own but I’m totally fine with it if it’s doctored up with stuff. : )

  • I am so glad I am not addicted to cookie butter, I can see it not ending well at all. I got some, I tried it, but thankfully I don’t have an addiction.
    However, I can imagine this cheesecake tastes quite fantastic because cookie butter tastes divine!
    Nice touch!

  • I love cookie butter, and I *love* cheesecake! This sounds like a match made in heaven.

    Want to hear a horrible mayo incident that has me scarred? I went to a church in junoir high where they had a game, oreo eating contest. You had to see how many oreo’s you could eat in 1 minute. But as a prank, half of the people where given oreo’s with mayo inside. Guess which kind I got? Yup. It was the grossest thing I’ve ever eaten! I never went back to that church either, ha!

  • There was a time when all my sis would eat was white stuff! White bread – white rice – mayo – yogurt – but they could never be togther!
    This cheese cake sounds so easy and delicious – but I am scared to try cookie butter as I have a serious addiction to ALL nut butters … 🙂 So, the way I see it only one solution – I come over to NYC and try a slice of this!
    Yah?!
    Happy Thanksgiving Pamela

  • This is making me so hungry. It’s like…. I feel naughty even looking at it, cause it looks so darn good! Loving the moving picture at the beginning too (Hark at me… moving pictures! I sound like an 80-year-old)

  • Incredibly creative cheesecake using TJ’s Cookie Butter! I am a cookie butter and anything gingerbread fiend. I’m glad you came around to liking cheesecake. Like Julie, I admired your animated gif! Best wishes for a very happy Thanksgiving! xo

  • Pamela!! I’m so excited…first because I can’t wait to try this cookie butter… but most importantly because we finally have a Trader Joe’s about 15 minutes from my house!! They just opened the very first one in Buffalo about a month or so ago. I’ve stayed away (believe me, it’s been hard..) because of the craziness and excitement of the new store, I wanted to wait until it calmed down a little. But now? yeah, I’m heading there…like..now I want to go there tonight. <3

  • Your mayo fear makes me giggle. When I was in junior high school, one of my good friends would always bring a cheese slice/mayo sandwich for lunch that would make me cringe. She always said it was SO good, but I never tried it myself. Eww. I don’t mind mayo, but only in very small quantities. A guy I dated loved the stuff and would literally smear like, half a cup of mayo on his sandwiches until it was literally oozing out of them. This cookie butter cheesecake sounds divine, and really makes me wish we had Trader Joe’s in Canada!

  • Haha, so glad Matthew was able to get you to try some cheesecake. you would have been missing out so much otherwise! (I happen to think that if you like cheesecake or cream cheese, you prob would like sour cream as well). Cheesecake is one of my most favorites desserts. I haven’t bought the TJ’s cookie butter for the exact reason you’re describing- i’m scared of becoming addicted! However, I’m totally going to have to buy a jar to make this…it looks so so good!!!

  • haha oh cookie butter. I have an open jar in my pantry right now and sometimes find myself sneaking in to grab a spoonful … oops! This cheesecake sounds absolutely delicious!

  • You’re absolutely right… cookie butter is like a drug. It’s impossible to stop at one spoonful. They are setting us up for serving size failure! I actually added cookie butter into crack pie last year (http://sharedappetite.com/crack-pie/) and it was a huge hit. This reminds me I need to start throwing cookie butter into pretty much every baked good from here on out.

    And I need this cheesecake in my life. Immediately.

  • Hehe, love that adorable runaway cheesecake gif 🙂 I’m not a big fan on plain cheesecake but when it’s jazzed up with other flavors – especially cookie butter – I’m all for it! This looks so pretty and sounds awesome 🙂 Love the melted cookie butter glaze – it looks amazing!

  • Yes to cheesecake! Yes to cookie butter! This looks delicious. You and me – opposite:) I love all things cream cheese, sour cream, ricotta, mayo, basically all things white and dairy! But especially cream cheese and honestly, its the best of them all, so if you like it, then you’re more than good in my book:)

  • Pamela,
    I love this post; for many reasons. First of all, this cookie butter cheesecake looks and sounds absolutely incredible. Secondly, you helped me to realize that I was too stupid (naive) to be afraid of making a cheesecake. I made my first one a couple of months ago, it was not perfect, but it really wasn’t that bad. That whole experience, along with your post, has made me appreciate the concept of a “healthy fear” of cheesecakes. Lastly, your post has caused me to have a very definite fear of cookie butter. It sounds like the stuff that dreams (and for me addictions) are made of. I must get to a Trader Joe’s!! Thanks for this post and all your others, I really enjoy seeing what you are up to, in the kitchen and on the farm. Hoping that you and yours enjoy a wonderful Thanksgiving holiday!!

  • Oh my gosh!!!! Pam, this cheesecake looks absolutely heavenly… I’ve never actually eaten cookie butter (shock horror!) as it isn’t sold here but now I’m even more determined to find some now. Love the ‘sneaky cheesecake’ GIF too, ha! Gorgeous post xx

  • I have similar feelings towards mayo aka the devil’s sandwich spread. UGH. I can’t believe someone dared to put it on grilled cheese. I gagged just thinking about it.

    I’m so glad you came around to cheesecake though because YUM. And whoa to this!

  • I completely understand your mayo fear. Mayo and mustard are out for me, so we always had to check food in the drive thru too! This cheesecake, though. Cheesecake definitely intimidates me, but if it is swirled with cookie butter, how could I not make it!? 🙂

  • Pamela!!!!!!! I think this is brilliant! I’m pinning and making this tomorrow… I was going to make a carrot cake but I have to have this now, my 2.5 year old will probably never eat anything else ever again after having this… but we’ll cross that bridge when we must. Wheeeee!

  • I used to be scared of cheesecake too! But that was because I had a pretty bad one once with I was young, and I used to hate cheese 😉 But I love cheesecake now and yours looks amazing!! It’s a shame I probably can’t buy cookie butter anywhere near where I live….but after your description of how addictive it is, it’s probably for the better 😉

  • Cheesecakes are my favorite childhood desserts. When I became a vegan, I was afraid that I wouldn’t eat them again, and now there are just so many to make from vegan to raw! Love the animated shot, haha, I feel like a kitty chasing a toy mouse ;(

  • Oh Pamela, now you’ve got me craving cookie butter and I don’t even know what that is. We don’t have that here, nor do we have Trader Joe’s. Darn it! I feel like I’m missing out on something. And by the looks of that cheesecake pie, I am. And I just love that pie running away, trying to get out of your grasp! 🙂 It reminds me of a mouse… so I called my kitties over and they just stared at the screen, fascinated!

  • Oh wow – this sounds super delicious. And the pictures… yum!
    Ok, so I never had a fear of mayonnaise haha ;p I got quite the kick out of you recounting tales of your childhood though. I was just a plain picky eater until about my mid-twenties and didn’t even try cheesecake until then. I’m curious to try and veganize this pie!

  • I love your animated gifs haha, I’m imagining the slice of cheesecake with little wheels on it 🙂 I can’t believe I didn’t know about cookie butter – I must find it in the UK! And when I do, I will make this – because it looks amaaaaaazing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For more information contact Pamela at pamela@pamelareed.com.    |     Privacy Policy    

Do you want donut recipes sent to your inbox?

I think you do. Sign up for the Brooklyn Farm Girl newsletter and I will send you my newest recipes, gardening tips and other updates.

You can also follow me on Facebook for daily recipe updates!

This information will never be shared.