I’m obsesed with Peanut Butter and Pickles! I just can’t get enough of this combination!
Pretty much every single day for lunch or a late afternoon snack, I’ve been toasting up one or two slices of bread, throwing on some peanut butter, throwing on a big pile of pickles and then eating it up with a smile! Have you ever tried peanut butter and pickles? I love the combo of the sweet and the tart.
And my favorite Peanut Butter for this sandwich? I’m obsessed with Peanut Butter & Co’s The Bee’s Knees right now. You guys know my love for Peanut Butter & Co, but I am super in love with the sweet addition of the honey in this. If you’ve tried this kind of Peanut Butter or you have and love it too, then make sure enter the Giveaway down below where you can win 2 jars!
First up, toast 2 pieces of bread. I love the Light versions of bread nowadays, 1 slice is 40 calories. Love it. What else do I love? This plate that Katie gave me. Thanks girl!
Then I take a generous amount of peanut butter and put it on both slices.
I also usually take a big spoonful and put it straight into my mouth because I can’t resist.
Then I throw on a BIG (!) pile of pickles. This is my favorite homemade pickle recipe but for store bought I always go for tart hamburger dill pickle chips. 
Seriously, I load up on the pickles. Every single bite should have a crunch to it.
The perfect lunch!
Have you ever tried Peanut Butter and Pickles before?
Pamela says
Hi Alyssa, you made me so happy! We are connected spirited Disney PB and pickles sisters! Totally going to try pb and cheddar cheese… sounds amazing!
Justin says
This is crazy! I thought I was the only one who likes pickle and peanut butter sandwiches. Well, my wife likes them too, but other than that, I don’t know of anyone else!
I often eat them as a late night snack, but I prefer mine on soft un-toasted (is that a word?) bread.
Oh, and I love the plate. That makes the sandwich even better!
Anna Johnston says
No Way!!! This is not a thing… I love peanut and honey, and peanut and jam sambo’s, but never in a million would I have thought to combine peanut butter and pickels, gonna have a crack at it. 🙂
Pudyqat says
I like peanut butter and honey sandwiches.
Katy says
I love the traditional PB & Jelly sandwich
barbara n says
I like traditional peanut butter and strawberry jam!
Donalyn@TheCreeksideCook says
I am obsessed with peanut butter and just about anything, so I would definitely give these a try. People would think I’m crazy maybe, but so what!?! Thanks for a great idea!
Tracy H says
My fave is peanut butter and banana! I would love to try this brand of honey peanut butter. Yummy. 🙂
Christine says
I love to eat PB and Bacon sandwiches!
Mimi says
PB and strawberry jam!
Angie@Angie's Recipes says
We love peanut butter too! Never thought of pairing peanut butter with gurken…have to give it a try next time.
Deborah says
My favorite is Peanut Butter and Banana! I should try the pb and pickel!
Maria n says
My favorite is peanut butter and banana! Xoxo
Dandi D says
I like having spinach and cheese on my peanut butter sandwich.
Helen @ Scrummy Lane says
I just can’t imagine what peanut butter with pickles would taste like. I guess I need to try it to find out!
ela@GrayApron says
Oh men, I was afraid to go to your site when I saw the title in my box. Good for you, Pamela. You are definitely an original individual! And I love that cat face plate!
🙂 ela
Kim Henrichs says
I like honey roasted peanut butter with red raspberry jam on whole grain!
Sues says
I’ve never even considered peanut butter and pickle sandwiches, but I LOVE weird combinations and this actually sounds quite good to me 🙂 Love PB&Co, to!
theresa krier says
my favorite is peanut butter with peach jam, thanks for the giveaway
Emily says
Yummm peanut butter with more peanut butter!!
Carolsue says
Peanut Butter and honey or Peanut Butter and jelly
Suzanne says
Wow, I am adventurous, will try pb and pickle, always open to a new taste experience.
Abbe@This is How I Cook says
You know what they say about girls that eat peanut butter and pickles? whatever suits you!
Katie says
So glad you like the plate! You are more than welcome.
Fave pb sandwich is easily pb, banana, and honey. Toasted and all gooey and melty. I want one right now.
Eva @ All Books Considered says
Pretty boring but crunchy pb and raspberry preserves
Nora (A Clean Bake) says
You make PB & Pickles sound like the best thing ever! I have never tried it but now I am so curious.
Nora (A Clean Bake) says
PS: PB + Honey + Banana is my favorite!
Victoria says
I have yet to try peanut butter and pickles, but I definitely LOVE all things peanut butter, so I’ll have to try it!
Laura @ Lauras Baking Talent says
I read this book series where the girl is always eating pb and pickle sandwiches…but I’ve never been brave enough to try it. Maybe I need to just go ahead and jump in 🙂
cheri says
I had peanut butter and honey toast just this morning for breakfast, it’s one of my favorites. Now the pickles might take a little getting used to but I bet it is delicious!
Maria says
This is an unusual one but I really love to add pb to a quesadilla. My mom made them when we were kids.