1
Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie

Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie

The best FRESHEST Pumpkin Pie you can make!  This homemade Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins.  This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

I love pumpkin pie.  I just don’t love it, I LOVE it.  Thanksgiving to me means pumpkin pie.  It’s really the only time of the year I make a full pie and eat the entire thing. Ok, I lied about that part, I do it more than once a year.  So with us picking so many pumpkins from our garden, I decided  to make my favorite pumpkin pie from scratch.  From seed to pollinating to picking to baking – this is completely made out of love.

The best FRESHEST Pumpkin Pie you can make!  This homemade Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins.  This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

 The pie is so tasty due to the freshness of the pumpkin!  This is one of those recipes where it’s so near perfect I probably won’t ever try another pumpkin pie recipe again! 

The best FRESHEST Pumpkin Pie you can make!  This homemade Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins.  This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

If you can use fresh pumpkin please do, it really elevates the taste of a homemade pumpkin pie! If you’ve never made fresh pumpkin puree before, here’s a DIY post I made.  It’s easy – I promise!  Even better, it freezes great so you can continue to use it for baked goods throughout the next few months.  If you can’t make your own pumpkin puree, that’s totally ok, grab some at a farmers market or use canned pumpkin.  

 Either way – enjoy!The best freshest Pumpkin Pie you can make! This homemade Fresh Garden Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins. This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

The best freshest Pumpkin Pie you can make! This homemade Fresh Garden Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins. This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

The best freshest Pumpkin Pie you can make! This homemade Fresh Garden Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins. This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

Pin for later:
The best freshest Pumpkin Pie you can make! This homemade Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins. This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

Print

Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie

The best FRESHEST Pumpkin Pie you can make!  This homemade Garden Fresh Pumpkin Pie recipe uses fresh pumpkin puree made from scratch from your garden pumpkins.  This homemade pie recipe is easy to make with condensed milk, a pie crust and plenty of Fall spices. Make sure to add whipped cream to the top of the pie for decoration! This is always the most requested dessert for Thanksgiving!

Ingredients

  • 15 oz fresh pumpkin puree
  • 14 oz can of Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 9 inch unbaked pie crust

Optional

  • Whipped Cream

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
  2. Mix pumpkin, milk, eggs, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and salt in a bowl.
  3. Pour into crust and bake for 15 minutes.
  4. Reduce oven temperature to 350 degrees and continue baking 35 minutes.
  5. Let cool.
  6. Decorate the top of the pie with whipped cream.

 

This recipe is part of Meal Plan Monday Thanksgiving dessert party!

 

For more information contact Pamela at pamela@pamelareed.com.    |     Privacy Policy    

Do you love delicious and easy recipes?

I think you do. Do you want recipes, like Easy Slow Cooker Cabbage Roll Casserole, Creamy Cherry Tomato Sauce and Chocolate Donut recipes sent to your inbox? Sign up for the Brooklyn Farm Girl newsletter and I will send you my newest recipes, gardening tips and other updates.

You can also follow me on Facebook for daily recipe updates!

This information will never be shared.